skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

The food was great, the service was great, the special drinks were also delicious. First time in but definitely won't be the last.
Charles W. Hofker via google.com - Jul 1, 2022
What an amazing place! Super cute! Sat on the porch and had the best food. My three kids couldn't finish the huge fried calzone, tho they gave it a good go. The sweet and spicy chicken sandwich was absolutely amazing. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. Highly recommend for a family supper!
Lawnie Luedtke via google.com - Jun 28, 2022
With the staff that I spoke with was very informative regarding their menu and there hours of operation. I look forward ordering from there. Also, I want to see if they need any servers right now.
Crystal Colavito via google.com - Jun 26, 2022
The Owner goes above and beyond to make the customers happy. We will go there again. No problem.
John Vandyke via google.com - Jun 25, 2022
This afternoon we celebrated my daughters new job at Disney World at the Early American Tavern. They have a great space upstairs that accommodated all of my guests. Tammy worked with me through the whole experience. She is so responsive to emails, flexible and accommodating with my requests! She even allowed me to come in yesterday t ... read more
Coleen Ranzan via google.com - Jun 25, 2022
Great food, fun atmosphere, great menu. One of the best burgers I ever had. Come here Wednesday nigh
Great food, fun atmosphere, great menu. One of the best burgers I ever had. Come here Wednesday nights and play bingo!
Jack R. via yelp.com - Jun 22, 2022
Food was good. Service a little slow. Interesting history and pictures ... read more
Andrea Vignola via google.com - Jun 12, 2022
Everything is excellent here.. food, service, dining experience. Our waitress Danielle is the best and always a pleasure to have.
Jaclyn Guber via google.com - Jun 12, 2022
Early American Tavern has earned my personal “Best BLT” award. My sister loved her pizza, my mother loved the French onion soup. Everything was great about this place, especially the fact that the entertainment (a band at the time I was there) wasn’t at all overpowering. I do recommend it!
kaylee via google.com - May 19, 2022
Food was good. Service was good.
Karen Plaza via google.com - May 9, 2022
Best burgers I've found around the area! Also recommend there sweet potato fries.
Matthew Gardner via google.com - Apr 29, 2022
Food was absolutely delicious.
Thalia Carrero via google.com - Apr 22, 2022
Food is always incredible with decent pricing. Wait staff friendly, drinks are great, and the music is even better! My new favorite place in Sussex county!
Jessica Thompson via google.com - Apr 19, 2022
Food and atmosphere are awesome.....people are very nice and live music is grest!
Steven Wells via google.com - Apr 9, 2022
Admittedly I was skeptical since I have known this place only as the Sussex Inn previously, but I've been very happy in our 2 visits. The menu has a lot to offer and is continuing to evolve. The service was pleasant, and the vibe remains the same. Ideal mix so far. I hope it continues to draw the crowds it does!
Jeff DeYoung via google.com - Apr 3, 2022
Delightful experience. Great staff, very good food ... read more
Spencer Tucker via google.com - Apr 1, 2022
Friendly staff, quick service, good portions and good prices ... read more
Natalie Shearstone-Frato via google.com - Mar 30, 2022
Food was delicious and it was a very nice atmosphere 😋 ... read more
Victoria Matassov via google.com - Mar 27, 2022
Went here for dinner tonight and the chicken marsala was delicious! Had the wings with sweet chili sauce that were awesome for an appetizer as well. we had the greatest service from tammy and dani always refreshing us with drinks.
Morgan Smolen via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
Just visited the Tavern and the food was amazing!! I got the chicken cordon bleu and its the best I have ever had. Tammy our server never let us hanging ! Will definitely be back ... read more
Maddy Smolen via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
Great food. Great service ... read more
Pam D via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
Salmon gone wild and sweet Thai chili wings 👍 Great service always good seeing Tammy ... read more
calvin brook via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
Great food Great time Great service ... read more
Jonathan Sienkiewicz via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
Needed to find something to eat along our trip. This place is top notch! really amazing unique menu.
Needed to find something to eat along our trip. This place is top notch! really amazing unique menu. Prices are very good and portions are big. Highly recommended!
Michael M. via yelp.com - Mar 5, 2022
Delicious fish and chips, awesome. Pleasantly surprise eatery.
Carmen Clark via google.com - Mar 2, 2022
Amazing burgers and friendly staff.
Dannie Sinisi via google.com - Mar 2, 2022
Had a delicious mushroom swiss burger with bacon with a side of delicious (crispy) fries. Lava Brownie dessert with ice cream was awesome! 👍🏻 ... read more
Jeffrey Woolf via google.com - Mar 1, 2022
Went tonight for our second time because we received an offer for BOGO wings. The first time we had entrees that were really good so we wanted to go back to try some pub food. The wings were excellent!!! So BIG, crispy, and the flavor of the teriyaki and garlic parm was great. Our server and everyone was so friendly. Can't wait ... read more
Tammy Wright via google.com - Feb 25, 2022
Went tonight for our second time because we received an offer for BOGO wings. The first time we had
Went tonight for our second time because we received an offer for BOGO wings. The first time we had entrees that were really good so we wanted to go back to try some pub food. The wings were excellent!!! So BIG, crispy, and the flavor of the teriyaki and garlic parm was great. Our server and everyone was so friendly. Can't wait to go ... read more
Tammy L. via yelp.com - Feb 24, 2022
Good food, reasonable prices, historic building. The service was a little slow but we were warned before hand due to labor shortage.
NYSW Railfan via google.com - Feb 20, 2022
What a great burger!
Michael Hepp via google.com - Feb 18, 2022
Perfect, loved it ... read more
Leonardo Morales via google.com - Feb 18, 2022
Great atmosphere, good people and food. We appreciate our bartenders Brian and Heather.
Stacie Cawley via google.com - Feb 8, 2022
Love this place ! Good food and great service.
Joseph Caruso via google.com - Feb 8, 2022
Good food and good service. What else could you ask for.
Joseph Caruso via google.com - Feb 6, 2022
Ok I have been here in the past and it wasn’t great . They rebranded and I thought just another restaurant changing the name but no different . Boy was I wrong ! Food was excellent ! And service great too! We are looking forward to going back and trying more things on the menu ! And no I got nothing for leaving This review . We are j ... read more
belinda torres via google.com - Feb 5, 2022
Staff was very accommodating and covid conscience. Great atmosphere. Nicely decorated for the holida
Staff was very accommodating and covid conscience. Great atmosphere. Nicely decorated for the holidays. Owner said all staff are vaccinated.
Stephanie N. via yelp.com - Jan 25, 2022
Cute, cozy place! Our server was very tentative. We had wings as appetizer as well colossal shrimp.
Cute, cozy place! Our server was very tentative. We had wings as appetizer as well colossal shrimp. The shrimp had great sauce, but I wouldn't rev one for bc you get 5 for $9.50. The wings were good just a bit burnt to my liking. I got the half chicken which was absolutely amazing and my boyfriend got the NY strip which he said lacke ... read more
Jorja B. via yelp.com - Jan 21, 2022
Friendly service and great food!
Harry Moon via google.com - Jan 3, 2022
Friendly service, good food, cold beer and very reasonable prices.
Penny Post via google.com - Dec 27, 2021
Early, rustic restaurant, certainly on for the more historic in the area. Food is great and the hosp
Early, rustic restaurant, certainly on for the more historic in the area. Food is great and the hospitality is greater! Always a treat to go there.
Richard C. via yelp.com - Dec 17, 2021
Great food and service. Amazed how well the few people there worked together to make the customers happy.
Pamela Michaluk via google.com - Dec 12, 2021
Good food, great service. Our server Tammy was amazing, we had a group of 45 and she couldn’t have handled the situation any better. She provided us with a great experience, would definitely recommend.
Edwin Grimm via google.com - Dec 11, 2021
Had a nice experience here for dinner with a friend. I was able to speak to the owner and found out
Had a nice experience here for dinner with a friend. I was able to speak to the owner and found out he took over right before the pandemic hit. Luckily he made it through and people are starting to come back. He explained they have an almost scratch kitchen. They had some specials that looked really good but we just went with burgers ... read more
Sandy J. via yelp.com - Dec 7, 2021
Hubby and I came in for Linner yesterday, we had apps and a shared meal they feed you right here ! food tasted great! we left very happy ! Thank you !
Sally Lutz via google.com - Nov 30, 2021
Nice place! The burgers were very tasty and the staff was very friendly. Will definitely be going back.
Mark Szuszkowski via google.com - Nov 27, 2021
We had a delicious Thanksgiving dinner at this place. Very good service.
Denise N.J via google.com - Nov 25, 2021
Went here for thanksgiving dinner. 1st one after loosing my mom - food was as good as home cooked - all the sides you could want! My son got the ham - best ham I ever tasted. All and all - dinner made me feel like mom cooked it all for us ! Fantastic!! Can’t wait to try another day !!!
Jo Mama (Eatass) via google.com - Nov 25, 2021
Very friendly staff. The food hits the spot perfectly.
Steven Melamed via google.com - Nov 24, 2021
Some of the best food I’ve had. If you get a chance- try their pumpkin mash, it’s magical. If you’re staying at the nearby resort(s) skip eating there and come here instead- food’s much better and the vibe is awesome.
Aneesha Deshpande via google.com - Nov 21, 2021
Happy Reunion
Early Am erican Tavern in my earlier life was The Sussex Inn and I was a regular patron. I haven't been back in twenty years. What a nice surprise to rediscover this restaurant. EAT is certainly not the Inn. The menu is vast and varied. The food I have eaten there has been very good. The value is better than most other restaurants in ... read more
VitaUsa via tripadvisor.com - Nov 18, 2021
We are so happy to find this place. The food was excellent. The service was great. The loaded tots were great. The salmon burger didn't disappoint. So far one of the few places in Vernon worth eating at! The only thing I noticed was one of the old photographs had an inaccurate statement. Not a deal breaker. The building is gorgeous. ... read more
Rachel Kwasniak via google.com - Nov 15, 2021
Tried this place for the first time over the weekend. We had the bacon bombs, chicken cordon bleu, a
Tried this place for the first time over the weekend. We had the bacon bombs, chicken cordon bleu, and stuffed pork chop. Everything was really good especially my chicken cordon bleu. We definitely will return to try other dishes cuz they have an extensive menu and it all sounds good. The only reason I knocked a star off is the food ... read more
Tammy L. via yelp.com - Nov 14, 2021
Great time with family. Food was great and plentiful. Server was new and had an awesome demeanor ... read more
Thomas Swarts via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
Food was really good, soup was the best part!
Marianny Fermin via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Last night my friends and I came to play free bingo and have a couple of drinks and some food. I had so much fun. I recommend if your not doing anything Wedensday night go to early American tavern where the old Sussex inn is and play Bingo.
Mercedes Little via google.com - Nov 10, 2021
We liked the place quite a bit. We were staying at Crystal Springs and were tired of (mostly) bad se
We liked the place quite a bit. We were staying at Crystal Springs and were tired of (mostly) bad service and horrific prices. EAT (ha, just realized that) was about 12 minutes away. The service was very good- friendly and prompt- they weren't very busy. The pictures of the place make it look like a fancy restaurant, but it's more of ... read more
Christopher H. via yelp.com - Nov 9, 2021
Outside look is offputting, but inside was clean, the staff was very nice and the food was very good
Outside look is offputting, but inside was clean, the staff was very nice and the food was very good.
Saul C. via yelp.com - Nov 3, 2021
Great place to eat ... read more
Jojo Prez via google.com - Oct 30, 2021
Very good food and the service was great. Fun playing Bingo ... read more
Matt Fredericks via google.com - Oct 29, 2021
We went for dinner for my moms birthday, everything was amazing. Tammy was so kind and fantastic even with a bigger party. ADDED bonus is was bingo night!! free bingo and drink specials every wednesday night at 7! it was a perfect night out and we will definitely be back!!!
Jess Bahr via google.com - Oct 27, 2021
Good food and good friendly service ... read more
Joseph Tedesco via google.com - Oct 18, 2021
Mmmmmmmmmmmm!
Can't say enough great things. If you want a great meal with attentive staff and craft drinks you are in the right place!
Elizabeth V via tripadvisor.com - Oct 8, 2021
If you are looking for a great night out with delicious food look no farther! Great food, great drinks & great prices. History of the building - priceless!
Elizabeth Vaughn Cason via google.com - Oct 7, 2021
Fantastic dinner/drinks and service!! We stopped here by chance for a Saturday evening dinner...what a great find. The Early American Tavern is in a very cool old building, with the history to go with it. The staff was great, all very friendly and warm. Tammy and Mickey obviously do a wonderful job not only with management, but serv ... read more
Mark Paquette via google.com - Sep 27, 2021
Yummmmmy
Delicious food. Great atmosphere. Family friendly! We had a great meal and a great time. We will go back and bring friends!!
JenniferAB78 via tripadvisor.com - Sep 26, 2021
Good ... read more
Debora Lopes via google.com - Sep 23, 2021
Waitress is over worked.
Anna Marie Bancale via google.com - Sep 18, 2021
One of the best restaurant in town ....the have the best food in the area ...perfect ..love everythi
One of the best restaurant in town ....the have the best food in the area ...perfect ..love everything they have ... read more
Nunez M. via yelp.com - Sep 18, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire