EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN

Our Story

The Early American Tavern

Built in 1843 by Gabriel Coykendahl. It was originally known as "Frank U. Dixon's Union House." In 1904, it was sold and subsequently renamed “The Sussex Inn.” During the Civil War, the Union House was used as a recruiting station for Union Soldiers. This historic building has seen lots of famous faces, including Garret A Hobart (William McKinley's first Vice President).

A Flavorful Time Capsule

Step into Early American Tavern, and you step into a epicurean time capsule. With each dish, we aim to preserve the essence of classic American flavors that have stood the test of time. No frills, no fuss – just good ol' American goodness.

Your Invitation to the Past

As we continue our journey, we invite you to be a part of this living history. Join us at 9 Main Street, Sussex, New Jersey 07461, or click to order online. Early American Tavern is not just a restaurant; it's a journey through time, where the love for American comfort food is as timeless as the stories that linger within these walls. Come on over – the door to history is wide open! 🏡🍔🇺🇸 #EarlyAmericanEats